Research News & Features

Society

• Other Research Links
• Contact Info

• Home
• Arts & Culture
• Environment
• Health and Life Science
• Innovation & Leadership
• Physical Science & Technology
• Security & Safety
• Society
  • Current Research
  • Archive

WSU News Service

Contact: David Brody, WSU Spokane/campus academic director, Criminal Justice, 509-358-7952, brody@wsu.edu

Washingtonians Voice Support for Merit Selection of Judges

SPOKANE, Wash.- The results of a Fall, 2008 survey of registered voters across Washington state indicates that the state's residents appear ready to change the way in which the state's judges are selected. This finding is contained in a report of the results of a statewide survey of nearly 1,200 registered voters conducted by Nicholas Lovrich, Director of the Division of Governmental Studies and Services in Pullman, and David Brody, associate professor and academic director of the Criminal Justice Program at Washington State University in Spokane.

The survey found that only 26 percent of respondents rated Washington's current system of selecting judges as good or very good. This low rating was largely due to concern that, despite the fact that the Washington state constitution provides that judges are selected by nonpartisan election, 60 percent of the state's appellate and superior court judges were appointed to the bench by the governor to fill a midterm vacancy. Respondents also gave the system poor marks due to the small number of contested judicial elections held in the state. In 2008, only 16 percent of judges were opposed in their respective re-election bids. The 84 percent of judges who were not challenged, automatically retained their positions for another term.

"Essentially, we have an election system with very few elections," said Brody. "In a state with populist traditions, a system of selecting judges which largely prevents citizen input was predictably viewed as being undesirable."

In addition to asking about the current method of selecting judges, the survey also asked for citizens' opinions about the commission or merit selection system of judicial selection, which is used to choose some or all judges in 33 states and the District of Columbia.

Under the commission system a nonpartisan commission made up of both lawyers and non-lawyers interviews applicants and recommends nominees to the governor, who then appoints one. After a brief initial term, judges selected by this process must stand for a retention vote, where voters can decide whether to keep the judge in office or not.

As opposed to the current system of selecting judges, a majority of respondents (60 percent) rated the commission system to be good or very good. Judging from an analysis of comments on the survey, citizens based this positive rating on four factors: (1) the use of a nominating commission as part of the appointment process; (2) the fact that retention elections provide voters with the opportunity to vote for or against all judges; (3) the fact that all judges may be held accountable by voters without the need for a person to run against a judge in a contested election; and (4) that judges always appear on election ballots at regular intervals.

When asked to choose between the current system or a commission system of judicial selection, over 60 percent indicated a preference for adopting a commission system while about 23 percent preferred staying with the current system, and 17 percent were unsure.

"Our findings indicate frustration on the part of voters with the lack of actual input they have in the selection of their judges, and they want to have the periodic opportunity to hold judges accountable," said Brody. "The fact that the commission system does guarantee voters this opportunity is central to its appeal and why it was the clear preference of survey participants."

The survey was conducted during the Fall of 2008 for the American Judicature Society (AJS) and the Washington State Judicial Selection Coalition, and features a margin of error of +- 2.9 percent. Primary funding for the survey and report was provided by AJS under a grant from the Open Society Institute. Additional funding was provided by the Washington State Bar Association, Washington State University, and the University of Washington School of Law.

About the WSU Criminal Justice Program
The WSU criminal justice program, founded in 1941, is one of the oldest such programs in the nation. Ranked 18th in the nation by U.S. News & World Report in 2005, it is the home of the first chapter of Alpha Phi Sigma, the criminal justice honorary. Graduates of the B.A., M.A. and Ph.D. degree programs have distinguished themselves in law enforcement, juvenile justice, corrections, court operations, homeland security, industrial security, state emergency management planning, and program evaluation positions. A significant number of WSU criminal justice students enroll in doctoral programs. WSU launched its own a doctoral degree in criminal justice in 2003, and the students in that program may pursue both an M.A. and doctorate through coursework at WSU Spokane and Pullman.

About WSU Spokane
WSU Spokane is the urban campus of Washington State University, a land-grant research university founded in 1890. The campus features advanced studies and research in health sciences and health professions, the design disciplines, education, social and policy sciences, and science and technology. Washington State University is one of just 95 public and private research universities with very high research activity, according to the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching classifications. In addition, U.S. News & World Report ranks WSU as one of the top public research universities in the nation.

Web sites:
Public Attitudes Regarding the Selection of Judges in the State of Washington: Results of a Statewide Survey, 2008: http://www.spokane.wsu.edu/Academics/CrimJ/Documents/WA%20Survey%20Report.pdf
http://www.spokane.wsu.edu/Academics/CrimJ/Documents/WA%20Survey%20Appendix.pdf
American Judicature Society: www.ajs.org
WSU Spokane MA Criminal Justice: www.crimj.spokane.wsu.edu
WSU Spokane: www.spokane.wsu.edu
WSU Department of Criminal Justice: http://libarts.wsu.edu/crimj/
Division of Governmental Studies and Services: http://dgss.wsu.edu/

Related News

• Concern Over Economy Grows Among Washington State Residents

  PULLMAN, Wash.— The current economic crisis is important to Washington state residents. A survey conducted by the Social and Economic Sciences Research Center (SESRC) at Washington State University shows that citizens increasingly see the economy as an important issue faced by the state, as well as economic development and jobs as the highest priority for tax dollars. Asked which of several issues was the most important one facing the state, almost 50 percent of respondents said it is the economy, followed by health care and education (16 percent each), jobs and wages (11 percent), reducing taxes (5 percent), and the environment (4 percent).

• WSU Researchers Find Celebrity Endorsements Motivate Younger Voters

  PULLMAN, Wash. - Celebrity endorsements have emerged as an effective political strategy for engaging younger voters and getting them to the polls, according to a newly published study by researchers at Washington State University. Featured in the most recent issue of the journal “Mass Communications and Society,” the study by researchers from the university’s Edward R. Murrow College of Communication attempted to gauge the effectiveness of celebrity endorsement campaigns in lowering complacency among young voters and prompting their participation in the political process.

• WSU Sociology Professor Awarded Grant to Research Volunteerism

  PULLMAN, Wash.- A Washington State University researcher will receive a $190,560 grant from the Corporation for National and Community Service to expand scholarly and policy research and deepen understanding about volunteering, national and community service, and civic engagement in America. Associate Professor of Sociology Thomas Rotolo, in conjunction with Duke University Sociology Professor John Wilson, will examine how social contexts influence individual decisions to volunteer. Rotolo and his colleague will build on existing research to explain the variation in volunteering rates and intensity based on geographical differences.

• Offering Up Bad Jokes a Good Way to Draw ‘Friendly Fire,’ WSU Researcher Shows

  PULLMAN, Wash. – Offering up a joke – at least one of that isn’t politically incorrect or “off-color” – is rarely considered particularly risky socially. But a recent study at Washington State University suggests jokesters do risk receiving a surprising amount of derision from their audience – particularly when it’s made up of those they love most.

• Children’s Internet Use and Cyber Bullying

  PULLMAN, Wash.--Children left to navigate cyberspace on their own with few or no parental rules seem to exhibit more anxiety, more depression and less pro-social behavior, according to a study by Washington State University researchers.

• WSU Students Receive National Scholarships to Study in China

  PULLMAN, Wash.-- Two Washington State University students will each receive a $20,000 National Security Education Program (NSEP) David L. Boren Undergraduate Scholarship to study in China. A third WSU student was selected as an alternate.

• Study Finds Early Primaries Would Boost States’ Impact on White House Races

  As they prepare to caucus this weekend in the shadow of Super Tuesday’s much-publicized presidential primary, a new study by a Washington State University professor and political scientist suggests Washington’s voters could likely have boosted their impact on the race for the White House had they instead participated in an earlier primary process.

• WSU Researchers Report Statewide Decline in Child Safety Restraint Use

  Washingtonians may lead the nation in buckling up when they drive, but recent research at Washington State University shows the state’s drivers are not nearly so conscientious when it comes to providing proper child safety restraints for the children riding with them.

• WSU Researcher Casts Doubt on Reports of Increasing Violence by Teen-aged Girls

  While law enforcement agencies are continuing to report a rising trend in violent crime arrests of girls aged 12 to 17, a study by a Washington State University sociologist and her research associate shows there has been little actual change in the rate at which young females commit all forms of violent crime in the U.S. for nearly two decades.

• WSU Prof’s New Book Argues Corporate Media Influence Will Be Offset by Technology, Specialized Media

  While mass media corporations will grow globally and reach more people than ever in the 21st century, a Washington State University researcher and media sociologist predicts that the media giants won’t influence the world marketplace any more than they have in the past.

• WSU Researcher Says Satisfied Employees Key to Restaurant Profitability

  The “secret ingredient” for success in the restaurant business is more likely to be found in the attitudes of those who serve the food than in the food itself, according to a researcher at Washington State University.

• WSU Extension To Participate In Rebuilding Iraqi Agriculture

  Washington State University is one of five universities teaming up to rebuild Iraq’s agricultural sector by strengthening extension programs and training at Iraqi universities. The U.S. Department of Agriculture announced a $5.3 million grant to the consortium of universities to develop and provide training programs for Iraqi nationals to enhance the management, production and marketing for small and medium agricultural enterprises. Agriculture is the second largest contributor to the Iraqi national economy and employs one-quarter of the workforce.

• WSU Researcher Shows Your Spouse’s Personality May be Hazardous to Your Health

  To the long list of things to consider when choosing a mate, there is now evidence suggesting that your spouse’s personality can have a major influence on your own ability to recover from – and perhaps even survive – a major challenge to your health. It is a finding drawn from a study by a team of researchers including John M. Ruiz, an assistant professor of psychology at Washington State University, as well as Karen A. Matthews and Richard Schulz, at the University of Pittsburgh, and Michael F. Scheier with Carnegie Mellon University.

• WSU Researchers Explore Consumers’ Online Buying Behavior

  With U.S. consumers now spending billions of dollars online each year, researchers at WSU’s College of Business, including John Wells (l) and D. Veena Parboteeah (r), are discovering that retailers can add certain features to their Web sites that enhance the ‘entertainment value ‘of the shopping experience, prompting an increase in ‘impulse buying’ and driving up the amount of money consumers are willing to spend.

Research News and Features, PO Box 641040, Washington State University 99164-0932, 509-335-3581, Contact Us